Independent supplier audits: evidence beyond the questionnaire.
Valment helps organizations evaluate whether critical suppliers meet agreed security, quality, AI governance and contractual requirements. We conduct evidence-based second-party audits and supplier assessments, connecting supplier controls to the business processes, applications and data that depend on them. Our focus is AI and technology suppliers, and the suppliers of services your business can't run without.
Independent means we have no stake in the supplier we audit. We have not advised them, and we tell you about any other connection before we start.
What is a second-party supplier audit?
A second-party supplier audit is an audit of your supplier, carried out on your behalf under the audit rights in your contract, against criteria you agree. It sits between the other two kinds of audit: a first-party audit is your own internal audit, and a third-party audit is the one a certification body carries out for a certificate.
Our supplier is already ISO/IEC 27001 certified. Why audit it?
A certificate covers the supplier’s own scope, while a second-party audit looks at the service you receive and the obligations in your contract. The certificate shows the supplier runs an information security management system for that scope, assessed by its certification body, and that is good evidence. A sensible first step is to read the certificate’s scope and the supplier’s Statement of Applicability, then audit where the service you depend on falls outside them.
Why supplier questionnaires are not always enough
A questionnaire tells you what a supplier says about its controls. For most suppliers that's a sensible place to start, and often all you need. For the few whose service your processes depend on, or who run AI on your data, you may want to see how those controls operate: the records, the configurations, the change history and the people who run them.
A second-party audit gives you that view. It is carried out on your behalf, under the audit rights in your contract, against criteria you have agreed. The questionnaire stays useful, and the audit shows which of its answers hold in day-to-day operation.
What a second-party audit examines
We audit under your contract's audit rights, within the scope they allow. Inside that scope, the audit usually looks at five things.
How the supplier protects the information and the service it provides to you: access, changes, incidents, continuity, and the subcontractors it relies on.
Where the supplier's service includes an AI system, how it is governed: who is responsible for what across its life cycle, how model and data changes are controlled, how the system is monitored, and what you are told about it as the customer.
Whether the products and services you receive match what was agreed, and how the supplier controls the processes that produce them.
The obligations the supplier accepted: service levels, notification duties, subcontracting, data handling and location, and cooperation with audits.
Which of your processes, applications and data rely on the supplier's controls. Findings are then read against what is at stake for you, rather than in the abstract.
We work from evidence the supplier makes available: documents, records, system extracts, interviews and observation. Technical security testing is outside the scope of a supplier audit.
Applicable ISO standards and contractual requirements
The ISO clauses below describe what an organization should do about its own suppliers. In a second-party audit they help set the criteria: what the supplier needs to show so that your own controls hold. Which criteria apply is agreed with you in the audit plan before any work starts.
| Criterion | What it covers |
|---|---|
| ISO/IEC 42001, Annex A.10 | Third-party and customer relationships for AI systems: responsibilities allocated between you, your suppliers and other parties across the AI system life cycle, and supplier services aligned with your approach to responsible development and use of AI. |
| ISO/IEC 27001, Annex A 5.19–5.23 | Information security in supplier relationships: the supplier agreement, the ICT supply chain, monitoring and review of supplier services and their changes, and the use of cloud services. |
| ISO 9001, clause 8.4 | Control of externally provided processes, products and services: the criteria for evaluating, selecting and monitoring suppliers, and the information you give them. |
| Your contract with the supplier | The clauses the supplier agreed to, including service levels, notification, subcontracting, data handling and audit cooperation. |
| Your own controls | Requirements you define for the supplier, for example from your policies, your risk assessment or a customer's demands on you. |
In Canada, OSFI's Guideline B-10 expects federally regulated financial institutions to have the right to conduct or commission an independent audit of a third party, and to use a range of audit and information-gathering methods, including individually performed or pooled audits.
Our audit approach and deliverables
Our audits follow the guidance in ISO 19011. We agree the scope and criteria with you, check them against the audit clause in your contract, and plan the audit with the supplier. Evidence comes from documents, records, interviews and the systems themselves, on site or remotely, and the audit closes with a meeting with the supplier before the report goes to you.
Supplier evidence is the supplier's confidential information, so we handle it under the confidentiality terms of your contract. Whether any AI tools may be used to analyse it is agreed in the audit plan.
- The audit plan and criteria, agreed with you before the audit
- Findings and nonconformities, each traceable to its evidence
- Risk observations and corrective action expectations
- A report and a management summary, addressed to you
A supplier audit gives you evidence and findings against the criteria we agree with you. It is not a certification, a SOC 2 report or a public accountant's report, and we don't review financial statements. What you do with the findings, including any decision about the supplier, stays with you.
A good place to start is the supplier, the service it provides to you, and the audit clause in your contract. We'll come back with a proposed scope and audit plan.
What if our contract has no audit clause?
We audit only within what your contract allows, so without audit rights a full audit isn’t the route. The usual alternative is a supplier assessment, based on the documents and answers the supplier provides. The audit clause is worth reviewing with your counsel when the contract comes up for renewal.
Will you audit a supplier you’ve advised?
No. Independent means we have no stake in the supplier we audit. We have not advised them, and we tell you about any other connection before we start.
How does this relate to OSFI Guideline B-10?
OSFI’s Guideline B-10 expects federally regulated financial institutions to have the right to conduct or commission an independent audit of a third party, and to use a range of audit and information-gathering methods, including individually performed or pooled audits. A second-party supplier audit is one such method. Whether it meets an institution’s own obligations under the guideline is for the institution to judge.
What do we get, and what do we provide?
You get the audit plan and criteria, findings and nonconformities traceable to evidence, risk observations and corrective action expectations, and a report with a management summary. You provide the contract and its audit clause, a contact at the supplier, and your own requirements for the supplier.
· Page owner: Valment Partners Inc.
Discuss a Supplier Audit
Tell us which supplier, what it provides and what your contract allows. We'll suggest a scope and the criteria that fit.